Skip to content
WE CONYA / Research
All case files ←

International Criminal Court · ICC-01/09-02/11

Five charges confirmed. A trial that never opened.

Prosecutors alleged Uhuru Kenyatta helped arrange attacks in Nakuru and Naivasha. They withdrew the charges in 2014, and judges later found Kenya had failed to cooperate.

5 counts Confirmed against Kenyatta and Muthaura

ICC pretrial confirmation

2016 finding Kenya failed to comply with ICC cooperation obligations

ICC Trial Chamber V(B)

View original editorial graphicProsecutors alleged that Kenyatta helped organise attacks on civilians in Nakuru and Naivasha. He denied the charges. AI portrait of William Ruto.

Original CONYA editorial graphic · AI portrait, not an archive photograph or evidence of an individual’s responsibility.

Download portrait card ↓
Uhuru Kenyatta at the ICC status conference, The Hague, 8 October 2014.

Uhuru Kenyatta at the ICC status conference, The Hague, 8 October 2014.

© ICC-CPI · Source ↗ · License ↗

Prosecutors alleged organised reprisals

Prosecutors alleged Kenyatta and Francis Muthaura helped mobilise Mungiki and allied groups to attack perceived ODM supporters in Nakuru and Naivasha. A pretrial majority confirmed five charges in January 2012, covering murder, deportation or forcible transfer, rape, persecution and other inhumane acts. It declined to confirm charges against then-police commissioner Mohamed Hussein Ali. Kenyatta and Muthaura denied responsibility.

Claim provenance: [1] ICC confirmation, paras. 113–178 and 428–430 [2] Contemporaneous Human Rights Watch investigation

Witness problems and the Muthaura withdrawal

The prosecutor withdrew Muthaura’s charges in March 2013. A later public filing quoting her submission records the prosecution’s statement that people who might have provided evidence had been killed or had died and that others refused to speak. A key witness acknowledged lying about parts of his account and accepting money to withdraw his testimony. The filing supplies no basis to attribute any death to a named defendant.

Claim provenance: [3] Prosecutor’s Muthaura withdrawal statement [4] ICC termination of Muthaura proceedings [5] Human Rights Watch on the withdrawn witness evidence [6] Prosecution’s public filing, Jan. 2014, p. 7 n. 15

Charges withdrawn and proceedings terminated

Key accounts were changed or withdrawn. The prosecutor sought banking, telephone, tax and other records from Kenyan authorities. Judges refused another adjournment. On 5 December 2014, the prosecutor withdrew Kenyatta’s charges, saying the available evidence was insufficient to prove criminal responsibility beyond reasonable doubt. Judges terminated proceedings in March 2015. The trial never opened.

Claim provenance: [7] Prosecutor’s withdrawal notice [8] ICC decision terminating proceedings

Judges found the Kenyan government failed to cooperate

On 19 September 2016, ICC judges found that Kenya’s failure to comply with a cooperation request prevented the court from exercising its functions. They referred Kenya to the Assembly of States Parties. This ruling concerned the state’s obligations and made no criminal finding against Kenyatta.

Claim provenance: [9] ICC non-cooperation judgment [10] ICC summary of the referral

Later public roles and other names in the record

Ruto appointed Francis Muthaura to a five-year term as chancellor of public Kenyatta University in 2024. The university reported Muthaura serving in that role in August 2026. Retired President Uhuru Kenyatta served on the African Union’s peace facilitation panel for eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo in October 2026.

The prosecution’s public redacted brief named current Naivasha MP Jayne Kihara as an alleged intermediary for recruitment. Kihara denied planning or organizing the attacks. She was not charged by the ICC and the allegation was never tried.

Claim provenance: [11] Kenya Gazette, appointment [12] Kenyatta University, August 2026 [13] African Union, October 2026 [14] ICC prosecutor’s redacted brief, paragraph 71 [15] Parliament profile [16] Kihara’s response

Footnotes & source documents

  1. ICC confirmation, paras. 113–178 and 428–430 ↗
  2. Contemporaneous Human Rights Watch investigation ↗
  3. Prosecutor’s Muthaura withdrawal statement ↗
  4. ICC termination of Muthaura proceedings ↗
  5. Human Rights Watch on the withdrawn witness evidence ↗
  6. Prosecution’s public filing, Jan. 2014, p. 7 n. 15 ↗
  7. Prosecutor’s withdrawal notice ↗
  8. ICC decision terminating proceedings ↗
  9. ICC non-cooperation judgment ↗
  10. ICC summary of the referral ↗
  11. Kenya Gazette, appointment ↗
  12. Kenyatta University, August 2026 ↗
  13. African Union, October 2026 ↗
  14. ICC prosecutor’s redacted brief, paragraph 71 ↗
  15. Parliament profile ↗
  16. Kihara’s response ↗

Further optional archive

Kenyatta appears at the ICC

Contemporary reporting and photographs of President Uhuru Kenyatta arriving for a status hearing in October 2014.

Al Jazeera and credited photographers

Link to publisher

Content warning: this optional external archive may contain disturbing accounts or imagery of violence. Third-party content loads only when activated.

Open original archive ↗

Naivasha after the attacks

An archival photo insert documenting the effects of the broader post-election violence in Naivasha.

Photographer credits appear in the source PDF

Link to publisher. Contains graphic images.

Content warning: this optional external archive may contain disturbing accounts or imagery of violence. Third-party content loads only when activated.

Open original archive ↗